Choosing AI tools: an evaluation scorecard for SMEs
Two AI tools can produce equally convincing demonstrations and behave very differently in daily work. Give both the same task, difficult cases and operating constraints before committing to a subscription or building your own tool.
In this article
Write the job before comparing the products
Start with a sentence that names the input, the expected output and the person who accepts it. For example: turn an incoming service request and the approved help documents into a draft reply that a support colleague can check. Record how the team does that work today, including the time spent correcting mistakes.
Agree which cases the tool should leave to a person. A reply assistant might handle standard delivery questions while routing contractual disputes to the account owner. This boundary makes the evaluation repeatable and connects it to the priorities from an AI readiness audit.
Set conditions that every supplier must meet
Before scoring features, write down the conditions a tool must meet before you can use it. These depend on the workflow and the information involved. Ask suppliers to demonstrate them in the proposed product and plan, and keep the evidence with the decision.
- Data handling: which information leaves your systems, where it is processed, how long it is retained and whether it is used for model training.
- Access: how the tool respects user permissions, removes a departing colleague and separates customer records.
- Control: who can approve actions, inspect activity and suspend the workflow.
- Exit: how you export your information and configuration, end the service and verify the agreed deletion process.
Check the applicable contract and configuration, since an assurance on a marketing page may describe a different plan. The NIST Generative AI Profile provides a voluntary framework for considering trustworthiness through design, use and evaluation. Use the scorecard below to compare suppliers that meet these conditions.
Compare the remaining options on one scorecard
Use a small number of criteria with weights agreed before the demonstrations. An illustrative weighting is 40% task quality, 25% fit with the existing workflow, 20% total operating cost and 15% support and portability. Adjust those weights to your situation; a company with a difficult integration may value workflow fit more heavily.
Score each criterion from one to five and attach evidence. A five for task quality should mean an agreed standard was met on your cases. A five for integration should mean the handoff worked in your test environment. Leave an untested claim marked as unknown and schedule the check before choosing a supplier.
Run the same work through every candidate
Build a test set from representative cases you are authorised to use. Include ordinary work, incomplete inputs, ambiguous requests and cases outside the agreed scope. Remove unnecessary personal information. Keep a separate set for the final comparison so repeated tuning does not turn the evaluation into a demonstration of memorised examples.
Have the people who will use the output assess it without seeing the supplier name where practical. Record whether it was accepted, how much correction it needed and whether a serious error occurred. For a draft reply, timing ends when the reply is ready to send, so checking and editing count towards the workload.
Price the workflow and agree the next decision
Include setup, connectors, usage charges, review time, maintenance and the cost of leaving. Divide that total by completed tasks that meet your quality standard. A cheaper subscription can be the more expensive option when each output requires substantial correction. Use the same assumptions for every candidate, as in our guide to automation ROI.
Finish with a short decision record: the preferred option, the evidence, unresolved questions, a pilot budget and an owner. Set a review date and a condition for stopping. If no candidate meets the requirements, revisit the workflow or the build-versus-buy decision before expanding the shortlist.
Frequently asked questions
- Should a small business run a formal AI procurement process?
- The process can be short. Write down the task and mandatory conditions, use a shared test set and record the decision. This does not require a large procurement department.
- Can a public model benchmark replace testing our workflow?
- It can help identify candidates, but it does not test your documents, permissions, integrations or review burden. Use it as background and compare the tools on the work your team actually needs to complete.
- What if the best-scoring tool fails a mandatory condition?
- Do not approve it for that workflow until the condition is satisfied and verified. Document whether a different configuration, a narrower use case or another supplier can meet the requirement.
Related reading
Let's build something durable.
Tell us about your project. We reply within two business days.

